Vale's Emission Reduction Program (ERP)

Vale Base Metals – Ontario Operations?

Headquartered in Toronto, Canada, Vale Base Metals is one of the world's largest producers of responsibly sourced nickel, copper, cobalt and platinum group metals. In Canada, the U.K., Brazil, Japan and Indonesia, we produce critical minerals that power electric vehicles, create renewable energy solutions and help develop life-saving medical equipment.

Ontario is home to Vale’s global Base Metal Headquarters (Toronto), our Technology Development Centre in Mississauga, as well as our Port Colborne and Sudbury Operations. With Sudbury’s five mines, mill, smelter and refinery as well as a Port Colborne’s cobalt refinery, Vale’s Ontario operations are among the world’s largest integrated mining complexes. We produce low carbon nickel, copper and cobalt, in addition to platinum group metals, gold and silver.

Vale Base Metal's Sudbury Operations - Emissions Reduction Program (ERP)

The Copper Cliff Smelter facility has been in existence for over a century, during which time has undergone numerous transformations and upgrades. The Smelter produces nickel and copper sulphide and nickel oxide, with sulphuric acid as a by-product. These products are shipped to Vale refineries or to market.

A Voluntary Emission Reduction Program (VERP) was initiated for the Smelter in 1971, becoming mandatory in 1983 through another sulphur dioxide (SO₂) Control order, and was referred to in that Control order as the Comprehensive Supplementary Control system. At that time, the company program name was shortened to “Emission Reduction Program" (ERP). The SO₂ Control order issued to the company was to limit sulphur dioxide emissions to the atmosphere from the Superstack, Copper Stack and Copper Cliff Nickel Refinery Stack by curtailing production at the Smelter and CCNR on days when dispersion conditions were such that undesirable ground level concentrations (GLCs) of SO₂ were anticipated or experienced in the communities.

With requirements to reduce SO₂ emissions, Vale implemented several process changes over the years. Most recently, Vale completed the Clean AER project which focused on Smelter Converter offgas capture, sending the offgas SO₂ emissions from the converters to a new Wet Gas Cleaning Plant before being transformed in the Acid plant to become sulphuric acid. With over a 10-fold reduction in SO₂ emissions, the requirement for larger stacks was no longer needed and two new 450-feet stacks for the Flash Furnace bypass, Fluid Bed Roaster bypass, Fluid Bed Dryer, and the Secondary Baghouse, were constructed. Both the Copper Stack and the Superstack were disconnected in 2020, from the Smelter processes, and deemed obsolete.

Vale's Emission Reduction Program (ERP) has been adapted through the years and post AER, no curtailing of production at the Copper Cliff Smelter is required, as the Smelter is no longer considered a significant source of SO₂, with >90% of emissions actively captured through primary and secondary abatement equipment. Limited curtailment of SO₂ emissions from the Copper Cliff Nickel Refinery is still implemented. Both, the Copper Cliff Smelter Environmental Compliance Approval (ECA) and the Nickel Refinery ECA, currently require that information regarding dispersion potential and steps taken to address impact be shared with a wider audience, and as such, some pertinent information has been included in the sections below.

SO₂ Monitoring Network

Vale and Sudbury INO (Sudbury Integrated Nickel Operations - Glencore) jointly own and manage a network of 18 continuous SO₂ monitoring stations located in the community. The network is operated and maintained by a third party, BESTESCH, under contract. Please follow link to access data:

SO₂ Emission Dispersion Forecast

Wind Conditions (real-time) from the Frood Meteorological Tower.

Surface winds (10m Above Ground Level) Wind direction
(blowing from)
Wind speed (km/hr)
Upper air winds (114m Above Ground Level) Wind direction
(blowing from)
Wind speed (km/hr)

Predicted production curtailment at the Copper Cliff Nickel Refinery due to dispersion condition (updated daily at 8:30am, refresh to view latest results).

Date Dispersion Conditions Planned Emission Reduction (at the Copper Cliff Nickel Refinery) to Control Ground Level SO₂ Concentrations (GLCs)
None Light Moderate Severe
Mobile SO₂ GLC Results

Vale’s Emission Reduction Program (ERP) has been adapted post AER, and active, routine mobile monitoring of SO₂ emissions in the community is no longer conducted. The mobile unit is available to respond to community complaints if and when needed, but no routine measurements are being conducted.

Limitations

The real-time data presented on this site has not yet undergone validation. The data should be considered “unverified” and should not be used in published documents. The data may contain errors related to instrument malfunctions, telemetry connectivity, QA/QC requirements, instrument calibration times or power outages, and is subject to change once validated. Validated historical data, as reported quarterly to the MECP, is available upon request.

The information presented on this website is intended for public awareness, education and information purposes only. It is not intended to provide medical or health care advice and should not be relied upon for such purposes. BESTECH, Vale and Glencore are not health care professionals. If you are feeling unwell, please contact a qualified healthcare professional for guidance.

The information presented on this website is not meant for emergency response purposes. This website does not replace or supplement Vale and Glencore’s existing emergency notification and response protocols.

Sudbury's SO₂ Air Quality Monitoring Network

Welcome to Sudbury's Air Quality Monitoring Network Portal

This site provides real-time data about ambient air quality, specifically SO₂ levels, in the Sudbury Area
Wind Conditions
Frood Road Met Tower
11.48 km/h (NNW)
N S E W NW SW EW NE
Falconbridge Met Tower
28.74 km/h (NW)
N S E W NW SW EW NE
Real Time SO₂ Measured Data

Legend
SO₂ Station
MET Station
Industry
Instructions
Click on a station on the map above to view real time SO₂ data at that station. Select 5min or 1hr average SO₂ data. Return to Main Page for additional information and context.
Limitations
The real-time information presented on this site has not yet undergone validation. The data presented on this website is intended for public awareness, education and information purposes only. It is not intended to provide medical or health care advice and should not be relied upon for such purposes.
Air Quality Index
1hr SO₂ Concentration Air Quality Index
0 - 40 ppb Good
40 - 120 ppb Moderate
120 - 250 ppb Poor
> 250 ppb Very Poor
Return to Main Page for additional information and context.

On this Page

What is Sulphur Dioxide?

Sulphur dioxide (SO₂) is a colourless gas with a pungent odour comparable to burnt matches. It occurs in the air we breathe mostly from volcanic eruptions, power plants burning fossil fuels, and smelting processes such as those operated by Vale and Glencore in the Sudbury Area.

What are the Health Effects of Sulphur Dioxide?

Under normal ambient environmental conditions of exposure, inhalation of sulphur dioxide is not likely to produce adverse effects in the general population. Asthmatics, children, older adults and those with underlying respiratory conditions are more susceptible to the respiratory effects of SO₂. Health effects from exposure to SO₂ and related acid aerosols are eye irritation, shortness of breath and reduced lung function.

For more information on SO₂, please visit:
Sudbury Public Health District
Ministry of Environment, Conservation and Parks
Environment and Climate Change Canada

For more information about air quality in Ontario (not just SO₂), please visit the Ontario Air Quality Health Index.

SO₂ Benchmarks and Regulations

Ontario Ambient Air Quality Criteria (AAQC)
10-minute AAQC: 67 ppb
1-hour AAQC: 40 ppb
Annual AAQC: 4 ppb

Ontario Regulation 419/05 Benchmarks
1-hour standard: 40 ppb
1-hour upper risk threshold: 250ppb
Annual standard: 4 ppb

Air Quality Index

The following categorization provides an indication of the potential health effects of increasing levels of SO₂:

1hr SO₂ Concentration Air Quality Index Cautionary Statement
0 - 40 ppb Good --
40 - 120 ppb Moderate No need to modify usual outdoor activities unless experiencing symptoms such as coughing or throat irritation.
120 - 250 ppb Poor People with asthma should consider limiting outdoor exertion
> 250 ppb Very Poor Children, people with asthma, or other lung diseases, should limit outdoor exertion.
ppb = parts per billion
Monitoring Sulphur Dioxide in the Sudbury Area

One of the largest SO₂ monitoring networks in Canada, the Sudbury Air Quality Monitoring Network consists of 18 SO₂ monitoring stations throughout the Greater Sudbury Area, as well as two meteorological stations that measure wind speed, wind direction and temperature. The monitoring stations are continuously operated and maintained in accordance with the MECP's Operations Manual for Air Quality Monitoring in Ontario.

Algonquin SO₂ Station
Wahnapitae SO₂ Station
Delki Dozzi SO₂ Station
Data Collection

In accordance with the MECP's Operations Manual for Air Quality Monitoring in Ontario, air quality data is collected continuously and stored as 5min average values. Those 5min average values are further averaged, on a rolling 1hr basis, for comparison against various benchmarks. Both the 5min average data and the rolling 1hr average data are presented on this site in real-time.

The real-time data presented on this site has not yet undergone validation. The data may contain errors related to instrument malfunctions, telemetry connectivity, QA/QC requirements, instrument calibration times or power outages, and is subject to change once validated. BESTECHvalidates the data monthly, or more frequently as required to ensure accurate data collection, and that validated data is reported to the MECP quarterly and is available upon request.

About BESTECH

For over 20 years, BESTECH has managed the Sudbury Air Quality Monitoring Network, including operations, maintenance and reporting, as an independent third party on behalf of Glencore and Vale. The remote real time data not only informs Vale and Glencore operations to help maximize production while ensuring legislative compliance, but also builds trust within the community through transparent communication of the real time SO₂ data on this website.

Contact Information
BESTECH On-Call
705-698-9969
Vale Community Concerns
705-222-VALE (8253)
Glencore Sudbury INO Community Hotline
705-693-2761 ext 3989
Limitations

The real-time data presented on this site has not yet undergone validation. The data should be considered "unverified" and should not be used in published documents. The data may contain errors related to instrument malfunctions, telemetry connectivity, QA/QC requirements, instrument calibration times or power outages, and is subject to change once validated. Validated historical data, as reported quarterly to the MECP, is available upon request.

The information presented on this website is intended for public awareness, education and information purposes only. It is not intended to provide medical or health care advice and should not be relied upon for such purposes. BESTECH, FROSKR, Vale and Glencore are not health care professionals. If you are feeling unwell, please contact a qualified healthcare professional for guidance.

The information presented on this website is not meant for emergency response purposes. This website does not replace or supplement Vale and Glencore's existing emergency notification and response protocols.